BEHAVIORAL ANALYSIS OF EMILLA CARR

 

               BEHAVIORAL ANALYSIS OF EMILLA CARR

___________________________________________________________________________

Amelia Carr, known as Emilia Lily Carr in some records, is a case 

study in behavioral analysis due to her involvement in the murder 

of Heather Strong. Here's a comprehensive analysis based on 

available information:

__________________________________________

Background and Context

Personal History: Emilia Carr was born on August 4, 1984, in 

Florida. Her early life was marked by significant trauma, including 

reported sexual abuse by her father, which he was convicted for

 attempting to silence by soliciting her murder along with her 

mother and sister in 2004. This background of abuse and 

dysfunctional family dynamics likely played a critical role in her 

psychological development.

Criminal History: Before the murder, Carr had legal issues, 

including probation for involvement in her ex-husband's theft of 

exotic birds. She was married twice and had multiple children, 

highlighting a pattern of unstable relationships.

_______________________________________________

Behavioral Analysis

Motivation: 

Jealousy and Betrayal:

 The primary motive behind Heather Strong's murder was rooted in

 a love triangle. Carr was pregnant with Joshua Fulgham's child at

 the time, and there was a deep-seated jealousy towards Strong,

 who was married to Fulgham. The crime was premeditated, 

involving luring Strong into a trap, indicating a motive driven by 

revenge and a desire to eliminate a perceived rival.

_______________________________________

Crime Scene Behavior:

Organized vs. Disorganized:

 Carr's actions suggest she was somewhat organized. She and 

Fulgham planned the murder, tried to cover up by moving the 

body, and attempted to control the narrative post-crime. However, 

elements like the chaotic struggle at the scene and the use of a 

storage trailer indicate some disorganized aspects, perhaps due to 

emotional volatility or lack of experience in committing such a 

crime.

Method:

 The method of killing, involving suffocation with a plastic bag and taping 

Strong to a chair, shows a personal, hands-on approach, which can indicate

 a need for control over the victim and the situation.

___________________________________________________

Psychological Profile:

Personality Traits: 

Carr's behavior might indicate traits like manipulation, lack of 

empathy or remorse (as noted in some sources where she seems 

"smug" even after the crime), and possibly an antisocial 

personality disorder where she uses charm or deceit to achieve her

 ends.

Impact of Childhood Trauma:

 Her history of abuse could have led to attachment issues, 

emotional instability, and a distorted view of relationships, 

potentially leading to violent behavior when feeling threatened or 

betrayed.

___________________________________________

Post-Crime Behavior:

Denial and Manipulation: 

Carr initially denied involvement, claiming her statements were 

coerced, and later provided different versions of events. Her 

refusal to testify against Fulgham and the way she interacted with 

authorities and family post-arrest suggest an ongoing attempt to 

manipulate perceptions and outcomes.

________________________________________________

Legal and Societal Impact

Conviction and Sentencing: 

Initially sentenced to death, her sentence was later changed to life

 without parole in 2017, reflecting changes in Florida's death 

penalty laws and perhaps also considerations of her background 

and behavior during trial and appeals.

Cultural Reflection:

 The case, particularly due to Carr's young age and gender, drew

 significant media attention, contributing to discussions about 

gender in crime, the influence of childhood trauma, and the death

 penalty's application.

____________________________________________

Conclusions:

Emilia Carr's case presents a complex picture of a person whose 

criminal behavior was likely influenced by a combination of 

personal trauma, relationship dynamics, and psychological issues.

 Behavioral analysis in this context not only helps understand the 

motivations and methods of the crime but also underscores the 

importance of considering early life experiences in criminal 

behavior.